Home Toms River Fight Continues Over Broadcasts At Toms River Meetings

Fight Continues Over Broadcasts At Toms River Meetings

Toms River Township Council members sit at the dais during the November 10 meeting. (Photo by Stephanie Faughnan)
Subscribe to Jersey Shore Online's EBlast

  TOMS RIVER – Assistant Township Attorney Jonathan Penney told a judge that letting the Township Council direct staff to livestream its meetings would be like letting it order police to remove someone from a meeting. Penney may not have realized that this has already happened in Toms River under a prior council president who happens to be a strong ally of Mayor Dan Rodrick.

  Superior Court Judge Francis R. Hodgson Jr. heard the remote arguments in the livestream lawsuit filed by resident Philip Brilliant. He has not yet ruled. The hearing followed new clashes over what airs on the township’s video feed.

  “Obviously there’s police at every council meeting,” Penney said. “Could the council pass a rule in their meeting rules that would allow them to direct the police officers as to when or how they would remove someone from the meeting? I don’t think so.”

  During his time as council president, Councilman Craig Coleman directed police officers to remove certain members of the public from meetings. The officers complied, even though the directives came from neither the mayor nor the police chief. Brilliant was one of the individuals removed from the meeting at Coleman’s directive on February 14, 2024.

  Currently, the mayor and his administration, Penney and three council members (Coleman, Harry Aber and Lynn O’Toole) are on opposite sides from the council majority (President David Ciccozzi, Tom Nivison, Clinton Bradley and Robert Bianchini).

Attorneys argued before Judge Francis R. Hodgson, Jr. who pointed out that he was not in a courtroom because of the shortage of courtrooms due to damages caused by flooding earlier this year. (Photo by Stephanie Faughnan)

Revisiting The Ruling

  In a September 16 ruling, Hodgson found that the council’s Rule 14 requires livestreaming of full meetings, including public comment. He also found Mayor Rodrick could not block it by withholding administrative support. Penney, who represents the township and the mayor, has asked the judge to reconsider.

  Penney’s filing cited a remark it attributes to Councilman Robert Bianchini at a September 23 meeting, “We’ll just blow it up tomorrow,” as evidence the rule was politically motivated. Peter Van Dyke, Brilliant’s attorney, countered that the comment came after the judge’s decision. He also argued the request came too late because the livestream ruling was final.

  Jason Senna of Archer & Greiner, special counsel to the council, compared the administration’s position to telling IT staff to block council members from using township email. “The IT infrastructure is there for everybody to use,” Senna said.

Mayor Daniel Rodrick’s seat was empty during the November 10 meeting. He attended the Veterans Day honors and left before the council began its business. (Photo by Stephanie Faughnan)

Who Answers To The Council?

  Under state law, the council controls only two township positions, the municipal clerk and the tax assessor. Penney argued that is enough for the council to stream its own meetings. He noted the clerk already posts meeting videos online. “The clerk already runs the video page,” Penney said.

  Van Dyke called that impractical. The tax assessor would be an obviously poor fit, he said, and the clerk is busy running the agenda and calling roll. He questioned whether the deputy clerk has the background to handle a broadcast.

  Hiring someone new would require the clerk and the business administrator to certify a need for the position. Van Dyke predicted that would never happen. “This administration, I would submit to your honor, would not have anybody certify to the mayor that such a position is required,” he said.

  On the township’s website, it says “The Toms River Township Tax Assessor is governed by State law and regulated by the (State) Director of the Division of Taxation while supervised by the Ocean County Board of Taxation.” Tax assessors are not overseen by the town so that there wouldn’t be interference; for example an elected official ordering them to reduce a family member’s taxes.

A Familiar Hiring Fight

  That concern comes from another part of the same case. The council voted to hire Noriko Kowalewski as the township’s records manager and council liaison. Senna, who represents the council in the council majority’s fight, said the administration blocked the hire by doing nothing. The judge previously sided with the administration, and the council has asked him to take a second look.

  Senna argued the township code gives the council appointing authority over positions in the clerk’s office. He said Kowalewski’s years as a high-level congressional staffer meet the job’s experience requirement.

  Penney countered that managing records under state archives rules is specialized work. “I think it’s a patronage hire, and I think it’s a waste of the taxpayer’s dollar,” he said.

Assistant Township Attorney Jonathan Penney leaves the dais at 7:22 p.m. while the council meeting is still in progress. (Photo by Stephanie Faughnan)

Legal Fees

  Penney also challenged the council’s contract with Archer & Greiner, which Council President Ciccozzi signed at $225 an hour. Penney said that rate exceeds any attorney fee in the township’s pool and that state law reserves contracting for the mayor. “I think you’re in a scary territory where you allow the council president to start signing contracts,” he said.

  Senna said the council is willing to compromise on fees and has already reached out to opposing counsel. Hodgson said a decision on all the issues would come in due course and “shouldn’t be too long.”

Videos On The Township Feed

  For the second meeting in a row, a prerecorded video aired on the township’s feed before the council called the meeting to order. The first time was on October 28 when a prerecorded video came on of Councilman Coleman accusing Councilman Nivison of misconduct. Those inside Town Hall had been told the feed wasn’t ready, and only learned of the video from people watching at home and texting them.

  On November 10, the face on the screen this time belonged to Mayor Rodrick. His video, a direct appeal to residents about affordable housing, ran before the meeting was called to order. Council President Ciccozzi said he had no advance knowledge of it. The council president starts the meeting.

  Council rules give the mayor his turn during the officials’ comment period at the end of each meeting. Rodrick has left both recent meetings before that period arrived. On November 10, he stayed only for the Veterans Day honors.

  On his way out, the mayor stopped this reporter in the hallway to put the timing of his video on the record. “The video was done before 6:30,” he emphasized, referring to the meeting’s scheduled start.

  Ciccozzi addressed the video before calling the meeting to order. “What he’s doing is he’s circumventing the judge’s order,” he said.

Coleman Censured

  The council then voted to censure Coleman over the October 28 broadcast. The resolution cited misuse of municipal property, an unauthorized broadcast, a breach of the Open Public Meetings Act and conduct unbecoming an elected official.

  Ciccozzi, Nivison, Bianchini and Bradley voted yes. Coleman voted against his own censure rather than abstaining. Councilwoman O’Toole, who participated by phone, answered “Absolutely not.”

Questions Go Unanswered

  Nivison pulled an agenda item about an emergency appropriation for tax appeal refunds and a settlement. Bianchini said the paperwork showed $1.4 million for refunds and $250,000 for the settlement. When Nivison asked Chief Financial Officer Dorothy Gallagher how much the township has in surplus, she replied, “I’m not authorized to answer any questions.”

  The council tabled the item, which means it didn’t get voted on. Not long after, Penney walked over to Gallagher, and the two left the room while council discussions continued.